Tag Archives: plotters guide

Plotters vs. Pantsers

To kick off this new blog, I want to talk about how writers write. If you interviewed 100 writers about their writing process, you’d get 100 different answers, some polar opposites, none wrong. The writing process is as individual as writers themselves.

Some writers start with a character or an idea or a flash of a scene. Just the tiniest spark of inspiration. They start writing, and they let the story unfold as they write. These writers are sometimes caled “pantsers,” because they write by the seat of their pants, following inspiration where it leads them.

Other writers prefer to plan before they begin writing. These “plotters” want at least some idea of a destination and some semblance of a roadmap before striking out into the unknown.

Plotting and pantsing are opposite ends of a continuum. Although a few writers (including me) fall on one extreme end or the other, most writers fall somewhere in the middle. Some do high level outlines but vary from it when inspiration strikes. Some plan a few scenes ahead. Some pour their hearts and souls into deep character backgrounds and then let their characters dictate the story events. Individual writers might even find that what works with one story doesn’t work with the next. Writing is individual to the writer, to the story, to the moment.

I am an extreme plotter. My professional background is in technical writing and instructional design, and my first professional writing was in nonfiction. Through nonfiction I learned how organization could make or break content, how structure determined whether content would be effective.

My first truly creative writing was screenplays. Structure is as critical — and omnipresent — in screenwriting as it is in a sonnet. With screenwriting I learned that structure could be the difference between mediocrity and art. I also had the importance of preplanning drilled into me by my mentor, a man who had made his living as a television writer for many years. It was, he taught, much easier — and faster — to make massive revisions at the outline stage than when you have a finished draft in hand.

And so, those were the lessons I carried with me when I began experimenting with prose fiction. To my delight, I discovered that nearly all of what I learned about story and structure in screenwriting could be successfully applied to novels as well.

I also found that the method I had worked out addressed many of the concerns and pitfalls that seemed to plague other writers. Pacing, character arcs, intertwining of events all falls neatly in line. I decided to share my method with others in hopes that someone else could skip over some of those concerns and pitfalls as well. Do I think my method and ideas are the only way to write a novel? Of course not! Do I think pantsers should abandon their preference and come over to the dark side? Yes! No, I’m kidding. I do think, however, that even die-hard pantsers will find something useful here though, because even pantsers have to deal with structure and organization during the rewrite phase.

Come on. I know it’s scary. Just give it a chance!

Postscript. . .

The blog originally started as a way to keep my friends and family up-to-date on my life and life around our little farm. Since the horses have moved in with their Aunt Leslie, the farm isn’t quite as exciting as it used to be, but I don’t want to abandon my friends and family. So at the end of each post, I will post a photo and a short update.

Pax and River in the snow

Pax and River in the snow

This is Pax (left) and River after the recent snow. River — affectionately called “Little Bit” around here — turned six months old on Christmas Day. As adolescence rears his head, he is turning from saint to holy terror, and we adore every minute of it.

Posted in Plotter's Guide | Tagged | 2 Comments